What Is Negative Gearing and Why Is It So Controversial?
For decades it was the most argued-about line in Australia's tax system. Now the rules are changing. Here is how negative gearing works, who benefits, and what the 2026 reforms mean for investors, buyers and renters.

Key points
- A property is negatively geared when its deductible costs, mostly loan interest, exceed the rent it earns. In Australia that loss can reduce tax on other income such as wages.
- About 1.1 million of roughly 2.26 million individual landlords reported a net rental loss in 2022–23, according to ATO taxation statistics.
- From 1 July 2027, established homes bought after 7:30pm AEST on 12 May 2026 can no longer be negatively geared against wages. New builds and homes already owned on Budget night keep the old treatment.
- Quarantined losses are not lost: they carry forward against future rental income or residential capital gains.
- The 50% capital gains tax discount is also being replaced with inflation indexation and a 30% minimum tax on gains from 1 July 2027.
What is negative gearing? In Australia, an investment property is negatively geared when the costs of owning it, mainly the interest on the loan used to buy it, are higher than the rent it brings in. The result is a net rental loss, and Australian tax law has long allowed investors to deduct that loss from their other income, such as their salary, which lowers their tax bill. Investors accept the yearly loss because they expect the property's value to rise.
That arrangement is now changing. In the 2026–27 Budget, the federal government limited negative gearing to new homes for properties bought from Budget night onwards, with the new rules biting from 1 July 2027. This guide explains how negative gearing works, who uses it, why it has divided the country for forty years, and exactly what the reforms mean for you.
Negative gearing explained in plain English
"Gearing" simply means borrowing to invest. If the income from an investment covers more than its costs, it is positively geared. If the costs are bigger, it is negatively geared.
The Australian Taxation Office describes a rental property as negatively geared when it is bought with borrowed money and the rent, after other expenses, is less than the interest on the loan. Typical deductible costs include:
- interest on the investment loan (usually the biggest item)
- council rates, water charges and land tax
- strata or body corporate fees
- landlord insurance and property management fees
- repairs and maintenance
- depreciation on the building and fittings, which is a paper cost rather than cash out of your pocket
What makes Australia unusual is not that rental losses exist, but where they can be used. As the Parliamentary Library notes, the tax system lets investors offset property losses against other types of income, including wages. Several other countries, including the United States, France and Finland, only let rental losses reduce future rental income.
How does negative gearing work? A worked example
Numbers make this much clearer. The example below is illustrative only, with round figures chosen to show the mechanics, not a recommendation.
Priya earns $110,000 a year, putting her on the 30% marginal tax rate plus the 2% Medicare levy. She buys an apartment with a $600,000 investment loan.
| Item | Amount per year |
|---|---|
| Rent received ($577 a week) | $30,000 |
| Loan interest | −$34,000 |
| Rates, strata, insurance, management, repairs | −$7,000 |
| Depreciation (non-cash) | −$3,000 |
| Net rental loss for tax | −$14,000 |
| Tax saved at 32% (30% + 2% Medicare levy) | +$4,480 |
| Actual cash shortfall before tax (rent minus cash costs) | −$11,000 |
| Real cost to Priya after tax | about −$6,520 |
Two points stand out. First, negative gearing does not make a loss disappear: Priya is still about $6,500 a year worse off in cash terms. Second, the tax benefit is worth more to people on higher incomes, because each dollar of loss is deducted at a higher marginal rate. On the top rate of 45% plus Medicare, the same $14,000 loss would save $6,580.
Who uses negative gearing?
Property investment is widespread in Australia. According to the ATO's taxation statistics for 2022–23, just over 2.26 million individuals had an interest in a rental property, and around 1.1 million of them reported a net rental loss.
Most landlords are small-scale. Analysis of the ATO figures has found that the large majority of negatively geared investors own just one or two properties. But the value of the deductions rises with income, which is the heart of the fairness debate.
Why is negative gearing so controversial?
Few tax settings have generated as much argument. The disagreement boils down to four questions.
1. Is it fair?
Critics argue that negative gearing mostly helps people who already own property and earn high incomes, at the expense of first-home buyers competing for the same homes. Supporters reply that it is not a special concession at all, simply the normal principle that the costs of earning income are deductible.
2. Does it push up house prices?
Combined with the capital gains discount, negative gearing made borrowing to buy established homes more attractive, which many economists argue added to demand and prices. Others say its effect on prices is small next to interest rates, population growth and slow housing construction.
3. Would rents rise without it?
Opponents of reform often cite 1985 to 1987, when the Hawke government briefly quarantined rental losses and rents rose sharply in Sydney and Perth. But The Australia Institute points out that rents in Melbourne fell over the same period, that vacancy rates in Sydney and Perth were already extremely low, and that the government's own 1987 cabinet papers blamed local conditions rather than the tax change.
4. What does it cost the budget?
Rental deductions reduce the tax the government collects, and that cost grows when interest rates rise because investors' losses get bigger. That money could fund other priorities or tax cuts elsewhere, which is why negative gearing was a central fight at the 2016 and 2019 elections.
What changed in the 2026–27 Budget
On 12 May 2026, Treasurer Jim Chalmers announced the biggest change to property investment taxes in a generation. Parliament passed the first stage of the legislation, the Treasury Laws Amendment (Tax Reform No. 1) Act 2026, in June. Here is how the new rules work, based on Treasury's published material and the legal analysis by Corrs Chambers Westgarth.
| Situation | What happens from 1 July 2027 |
|---|---|
| Established home owned before 7:30pm AEST, 12 May 2026 | Unchanged: losses can still offset wages and other income (grandfathered) |
| Established home bought after Budget night | Losses quarantined: they can only offset residential rental income or residential capital gains, and carry forward |
| New residential build | Negative gearing still available |
| Shares, commercial property | Not affected by the negative gearing change |
| Some affordable, social, NDIS and build-to-rent housing | Proposed exemptions in the second tranche of legislation |
The exact definition of a "new residential dwelling" is being set in follow-up legislation. Budget material points to homes that genuinely add to supply, are bought from a builder and have not been lived in for more than 12 months. Treasury consulted on that second tranche between 3 and 21 August 2026.
The capital gains tax change
Alongside negative gearing, the government is replacing the 50% capital gains tax discount for individuals and trusts. From 1 July 2027, the cost base of assets held for at least 12 months will instead be indexed to inflation, so only real gains are taxed, and resident individuals will pay a minimum 30% tax on those gains. Gains built up before 1 July 2027 keep the old 50% discount. In his second reading speech, the Treasurer described this as returning capital gains tax to its original intent.
What the changes mean for you
This is general information, not personal financial advice; see our disclaimer and speak to a registered tax agent or licensed adviser about your circumstances.
- Existing investors: if you owned your property before Budget night, its negative gearing treatment continues. Selling and buying another established property would bring the new rules into play for the new purchase.
- Prospective investors: buying an established home now means rental losses from July 2027 will mainly be useful against future property income and gains. New builds keep the full deduction, which is exactly the shift in incentives the government intends.
- First-home buyers: the policy aims to reduce investor competition for existing homes. Treasury's own modelling, as reported in the Budget coverage, expects only a modest effect on prices, of around 2% slower growth over a couple of years.
- Renters: the evidence from the 1980s suggests local supply and vacancy rates matter far more for rents than tax settings. Whether the reforms boost new construction will be the key test.
Negative gearing vs positive gearing
A positively geared property earns more rent than it costs to hold, producing taxable income from day one. It suits investors who want cash flow, such as retirees. A negatively geared property costs money every year and relies on future capital growth. With higher interest rates and the new rules, many investors are rethinking which strategy fits them.
Debates about how far governments should steer private markets through tax are as old as economics itself. If you want the bigger picture, our guide to socialism, communism and capitalism explains how mixed economies balance markets and the state. For more on the forces moving Australia's economy, visit our Australia edition.
Frequently asked questions
Has negative gearing been abolished in Australia?
No. It has been restricted. From 1 July 2027, investors who bought an established home after 7:30pm AEST on 12 May 2026 cannot use its rental losses to reduce tax on wages or other non-property income. Negative gearing remains available for new builds, and properties owned before Budget night are grandfathered.
Can I still negatively gear the investment property I already own?
Yes, if you held it before 7:30pm AEST on 12 May 2026. The government has said existing arrangements continue for those properties. Check how the rules apply to your situation with a registered tax agent, especially if ownership changes through sale, inheritance or separation.
What happens to rental losses that can't be deducted under the new rules?
They are quarantined, not cancelled. You can carry them forward and use them against future residential rental income or residential capital gains, but not against wages or non-residential income.
Does negative gearing apply to shares?
Yes. Gearing simply means borrowing to invest, so investors who borrow to buy shares can also have deductible interest exceed dividends. The 2026 restrictions target established residential property; shares and commercial property are not affected by the negative gearing change.
How much tax does negative gearing save?
Your tax saving equals your net rental loss multiplied by your marginal tax rate. For someone on the 30% rate plus the 2% Medicare levy, a $10,000 loss cuts tax by about $3,200. You are still $6,800 out of pocket, so the strategy only pays off if the property's value rises enough.
What is the difference between negative and positive gearing?
A positively geared property earns more in rent than it costs to hold, so it produces taxable income. A negatively geared property costs more than it earns, producing a loss. A neutrally geared property roughly breaks even.
- Negative gearing (Rental properties guide), Australian Taxation Office
- Snapshot of Taxation statistics 2022–23, Australian Taxation Office, 27 Jun 2025
- Capital Gains Tax and Negative Gearing – Tranche 2 Legislation, Treasury, 2026
- Second reading speech, Treasury Laws Amendment (Tax Reform No. 1) Bill 2026, The Treasurer, May 2026
- Capital gains tax and negative gearing amendments: key changes and implications, Corrs Chambers Westgarth, 2026
- Negative gearing (FlagPost), Parliamentary Library, Dec 2018
- Does negative gearing keep rent prices low? Check the facts, The Australia Institute
